Some of Our Questions May Not Be Working Anymore

— Six Shifts to Consider

by:
making-spirits-bright

Lately I feel some of the questions we’ve relied on for years just aren’t giving us all the info we need anymore.

I’ve been rethinking not just what we ask but how we ask it. Many consumers are making faster decisions today. Many younger consumers are switching brands more often. I believe many are reacting to things in the moment—whether it’s a TikTok Shop video, a group chat, or a post from a favorite influencer. And yet, we’re still asking questions as if consumers move through decisions slowly and logically, which is rarely the case.

Here are six high-level shifts that have helped me get closer to what’s really driving today’s consumers:

1

From “Why did you choose this brand?” to “What influenced your decision in that moment?”

Brand preference still matters—but it’s rarely the whole story. Someone might love a brand and still grab something else because it was on sale, better positioned, or just easier to spot. Asking about the moment of choice helps us get into real-life behavior.

2

From “What do you like about this product?” to “What, if anything, made you hesitate or think twice about this product?”

Positives are easy to name. But what almost made someone walk away? That’s where the friction lives. We’ve started asking things like, “What, if anything, gave you pause? That tweak has led to insights on everything from unclear packaging to subtle price sensitivity that we would’ve missed otherwise.

3

From “Which type of shopper are you?” to “What were you solving for that day?”

People shop differently depending on their mood, needs, or even the time of day. I’ve bought something practical in the morning and something indulgent later that night. (Haven’t we all?) Asking about their mindset or what they were trying to accomplish in that moment gives you more meaningful, usable insight.

4

From “Which brands are you aware of?” to “What caught your attention recently?”

We all know top-of-mind awareness doesn’t always reflect what’s actually working. And aided lists can make all brands seem equally familiar—even when they’re not. Instead, we’ve been asking things like, “What’s something that stuck with you—whether or not you bought it?” It’s been a better way to get at what’s breaking through the noise.

5

From “Where do you usually shop?” to “Where did you shop last time—and why?”

Shopping behavior isn’t static. People bounce between in-store, apps, delivery, and third-party sellers and rarely think twice about it. Asking about their most recent trip helps ground the response in reality and often reveals more flexible, channel-agnostic behavior.

6

From “Which ad do you like most?” to “Which ad made you feel something—and what was it?”

“Liking” an ad doesn’t mean it worked. But when someone tells you “That one made me laugh” or “That one felt like it was talking to me,” then you’re getting somewhere. We’ve also tried asking, “If you were telling a friend about this ad, what would you say?” That question gives us insight into emotional connection and message clarity in one shot.

The Takeaway

This isn’t just about rewording questions. It’s about rethinking what we’re trying to understand and finding smarter ways to get there. Great research doesn’t start with better answers. It starts with better questions.

The best insights often come from small shifts in how we ask, not just what we ask. And sometimes, rephrasing something we’ve asked a hundred times is what finally helps us hear the answer we’ve been missing.

Author

Deidre Hart

Deirdre Hart

Senior Vice President

Email Deirdre

Deirdre Hart has spent her entire career in market research designing and delivering strategic research for a range of clients across many categories. Her expertise lies within customized quantitative methodologies including extensive experience in new product development; brand, product, and packaging optimization; tracking studies; customer satisfaction; brand extendibility; image research; and experiential on-site research. Deirdre’s commitment to delivering insightful and implementable findings has made her a trusted partner for businesses navigating consumer preferences and market trends.

Copyright © 2025 by Decision Analyst, Inc.
This posting may not be copied, published, or used in any way without written permission of Decision Analyst.